Reviews

Review Snapshot
3.4
27 Star Ratings
60%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Hips/Rear
Overall size
Rise
Waist
Most Liked Positive Review
Comfort with style

All cotton fabrics are required for comfortable southwestern living. Meets my basic requirement. Runs large but not sure if I would have found a size smaller as comfortable. Length is ideal - will wear with boots or sandals depending on season. Almost has a western flare in the tan color so will pla...

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
Oversized and wrinkly

I was very eager to try this dress and scanned every image/video I could find online, but I was still very disappointed with all of my purchase-- either too big or too small. I do wish gap would be consistent with their vanity sizing-- it's like playing roulette with your final sale purchases. The...

Write a Review
23 Customer Reviews
nice, classic shirt dress

Submitted 3 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'6"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about GapStudio Poplin Belted Maxi Shirtdress

High quality dress. The fabric is a little stiff, even after washing and there's SO much of it. It can easily fit a wide range of body types. I would have sized down had I known.

Overall size
Was this review helpful to you?
Lovely tailoring but very very large. Order 2 sizes down!

Submitted 5 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'5"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about GapStudio Poplin Belted Maxi Shirtdress

HUGE!! If not for the great tailoring, it would look like a literal tent. As is, I'm already swimming in a sea of fabric (although in the best possible way). Order two sizes down - I ordered one sz down based on existing reviews - it's really large.

Overall size
Was this review helpful to you?
Another great poplin dress from Zac!

Submitted 5 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'4"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about GapStudio Poplin Belted Maxi Shirtdress

Love this dress!!! I have the white poplin GapStudio dress and needed to try the long sleeve navy one. It looks great and already got 3 compliments on it at work!

Overall size
Was this review helpful to you?
Just Say No

Submitted 6 days ago

By Norah

From Undisclosed

Height 5'8"

Weight 200–210 lbs

Ginormous doesn't begin to describe this dress. I am usually a 1x or 2x and 5'8". You could fit two of me in this XXL and it drags in the floor.

Rise
Waist
Hips/Rear
Overall size
Was this review helpful to you?
Runs large

Submitted 7 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'6"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about GapStudio Poplin Belted Maxi Shirtdress

The fabric is thick and nicer than expected. The dress runs very large and the small was baggy, but I'm keeping because it's a good basic for me. Also "gap studio" is embroidered on the cuff and I think logo location should always be publicized in the sale ads.

Overall size
Was this review helpful to you?
Oversized... but meant to be that way I think

Submitted 11 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'10"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about GapStudio Poplin Belted Maxi Shirtdress

I bought a large - my usual size but with much concern since other reviewers said the dress would be huge. It is a wide dress admittedly, however I think it was meant to be oversized and so I'm somewhat comfortable with it. I like that it is to my ankles and I'm 5'10 .... I haven't worn it yet to see how it fits with a full days wear but just from the initial try on I think its a long oversized dress meant to be styled as such

Overall size
Was this review helpful to you?
I think I like it - Intentionally oversized

Submitted 12 days ago

By Tori D

From Undisclosed

Height 5'10"

I was concerned after having read the reviews because I ordered my regular size - large. When the dress arrived it was indeed much wider than anticipated but im not as disturbed because I actually think it's supposed to be a bit oversized and long .... im 5'10 and it's at my ankles... I actually love that about it. Its kinda oversized on the models too if you look closely...Note this is my initial reaction after trying it on once .... perhaps I will return to edit my review when I've worn it for a whole day and see how it moves or if it feels too big.

Overall size
Length purchased
tall
Which size did you purchase?
Large

Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

Was this review helpful to you?
Comfort with style

Submitted 14 days ago

By Postmotherhood

From Hill Country of Texas

All cotton fabrics are required for comfortable southwestern living. Meets my basic requirement. Runs large but not sure if I would have found a size smaller as comfortable. Length is ideal - will wear with boots or sandals depending on season. Almost has a western flare in the tan color so will play that up with turquoise - or go with my equestrian-themed Hermes scarf. Read about this dress in a Wirecutter review - I had bad experiences with Gap 15+ years ago but I'm now back for GapStudio and GapX collaborations.

Overall size
Overall quality

Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

Was this review helpful to you?
Way too big

Submitted 14 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'7"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about GapStudio Poplin Belted Maxi Shirtdress

Toni's is a nice dress but the sizing makes no sense. I purchased a medium (I'm a size 8) I have it to my sister who wears a size 16. Runs way too big.

Overall size
Was this review helpful to you?
overall is good

Submitted 15 days ago

By Tugba

From Undisclosed

Size very big

Which size did you purchase?
m
Was this review helpful to you?