Bought this shirt last year in black and white and I wear them all the time, they are closet staples for me. I would give this item 5 stars for last year's version. I typically wear M Petite (L Petite for some styles that are more fitted or have little stretch) but S Petite in this shirt is still pe...rfectly oversized for me, so definitely size down. I'm around 5'1 and 140 lbs. I'm only giving this item 3 stars because this years striped styles have a different fit than last year and are unflattering on me. I was a bit disappointed when I received the blue and white stripe version and have it fit much differently on me - the cuffs are longer so folding the sleeves up doesn't look as nice, the collar is larger and sits higher than before so it looks more like a men's dress shirt as it looks like there's enough space to fit a tie under the collar, and the hem of the shirt is longer than before, which is particularly unflattering on my petite height. The overall fit makes the collar area more like a men's dress shirt as less of a shirt that can be styled down. Long review but tldr; new striped styles do not fit the same as previous years' black and white variants! Please bring back the old fit!