I’m usually a M Tall in gap shirts and I sized up to an L Tall based on reviews. I love this sweater! The bottom is banded/tighter which is the look I prefer, with it loose/oversized elsewhere. Might buy in a few more colors!

Perfect weight and drape to work for multiple seasons, i took advice of other reviewers and sized up to Large Tall

I wish I had read the review before chosing my size. I went down one size thinking it would be oversized as listed. It's roomy in the arms but cinched and a bit short at the waist. I love the color and the 100% cotton so I am debating if I should kee…

i like the sweater and im going to keep it, but the color of the ivory beige is closer to straight up white. it doesnt look nearly as beige as it does in the photos. im normally a size small and i ordered the large, and im happy witg the oversized fi…

This sweater is advertised as an oversized roll-neck sweater, but it’s not oversized at all! It fits more true to size, if not a little small. If you’re looking for that beloved, cozy, oversized fall sweater look, I’d recommend sizing up at least two…

This sweater is both visually stunning and incredible quality. I’m debating picking up another color while it’s on sale. However, I definitely agree with others that calling this sweater oversized was a weird choice. I sized up after reading reviews.…

Labeling this as oversized is kind of misleading. I sized up to medium and it fits like a small. It’s short (I’m 5’4) and you’d have to size up at least two sizes for an oversized fit. Otherwise, well made and a substantial weight. Will be keeping ev…

I saw this on a TikTok account I follow and noticed that she sized up. A couple of reviews mentioned doing the same, so I ordered one size up from my usual. I’m glad I did; it fits perfectly oversized, similar to how it looks on the model. I ordered …

I’m usually a size XS in Gap. I ordered in a medium and it’s still not as oversized as I’d like. The bottom part where it becomes cinched fits like an XS. I’d size up 3 sizes if you don’t want this fitted. Overall cute and great quality though. My me…

This is a solid, basic, heavy sweater perfect for cold and snowy days. The neutral colors and pattern are subtle and attractive. The sizing runs true. The sleeves on me are a little long but easily cuffed. Nice addition to fall/winter 2026 wardrobe!