Love the color and the removable fur collar. The coat should be very warm, cannot speak to water resistance yet. Great details like thumbholes and hand warmer pockets. Fantastic quality. It runs BIG. Definitely size down. It also is shaped like a triangle with no waist definition at all. I am kind of petite with an hourglass shape and it didn't really flatter me. I liked everything else about this coat, though, so I am having it tailored to create some waist definition. I think that will make it the perfect winter coat for my shape. If you like a very boxy, loose silhouette then definitely get this coat.