I really like this skirt and have been looking for something like this for over a year now. I am usually a 8-10-M in Gap and took a M in this. I will say that the liner wasn't great, it rode up and was quite tight, although the skirt itself fit well. I cut the liner out and will wear with my own mini half slip, which looks and feels better.

the material just does not scream quality. does not feel nice to the touch and its almost impossible to get the wrinkles from when it was folded in package out. theres gapping at the waistband. the slip underneath rides up.